Attorney Musca on Possibility Dementia Turned Law Abiding Grandfather into a Bank Robber

March 2, 2010
By Musca Law on March 2, 2010 1:33 PM |

Friends and family of James Bruce are trying to come to term with why a 73-year-old law abiding grandfather suddenly robs three South Tampa Banks.  Bruce walked into Bank of America on January 15 and slipped the teller a note demanding $600.  Tampa sheriff's deputies said that Bruce struck again in an identical fashion on February 1 at a SunTrust Bank and February 10 at another Bank of America.  During the first two robberies, Bruce left the bank on foot; the third he drove his old pickup.  Those who know Bruce point out he did not attempt to disguise himself or use a gun and asked for only a small sum of money.  The demand notes did not characterize his actions as a robbery and indicated that he intended to pay the money back.

An expert speculated on the cased based on the reports.  "Why only $600 if you're going to rob a bank?  Why not $60,000?" said psychiatrist Daniel Amen, who operates brain clinics across the country.  Amen said that Bruce's behavior is consistent with a condition called frontotemporal dementia.  Amen explained that the condition impairs the area of the brain responsible for planning and impulse control.  "Everyone has fantasies, but those with dementia are more likely to carry them out," said Amen.

Those who knew Bruce indicated he had started acting differently lately.  His family said they were concerned about him because he seemed to be having a hard time remembering things.  Tampa Detective Melinda Reuis disagreed saying that in the 90 minutes they spoke he showed no signs of memory problems.  "He's not losing his mind," said Reuis.  "For a 73-year-old-man, he's pretty with it."

Family members and friends also said he had started asking for small amounts of money from friends -- $10 here and $20 there - even after the bank robberies.  "I have known him for years," said Delia Urrutia, one such friend. "He never, ever, ever before asked for money.

Michael Lopez, who manages a plant shop next to Bruce's business, who had a chance to view the banks' surveillance video does not believe that Bruce was operating at full mental capacity.  Defense attorney John Musca commented that given the surveillance video and other circumstances of the case Bruce's mental capacity might be an important part of his defense.

 


Musca Law has over 100 years of combined legal experience with convenient offices located across the State of Florida.  Our Tampa criminal defense Attorneys will aggressively defend your rights on the State and Federal level.  The prosecution is looking to punish you to the fullest extent of the law.  You need a knowledgeable attorney to watch out for you.  Contact the Tampa criminal lawyers at Musca Law for a free, comprehensive review of your case.